Search Result

[Subwoofer]

Got a friend who's a support worker in higher education who's been told she'll be working from home until January !!!!...

[Subwoofer]

Somebody posted elsewhere there's now more R1b CW than R1a which took me rather by surprise since these R1b results are relatively new whilst they've been digging up R1a CW for years now.

[Subwoofer]

More than silly, it's close to making the whole exercise pointless.

With everything that's going on at the moment I'm close to following the lead of others and throwing the towel in....

[Subwoofer]

If it were that simple everybody would be insisting P312 originated in Ireland but most folk don't even think M222 was conceived there now....

[Subwoofer]

Thought this thread was Blood of the Celts, not Belligerent Irish : )...

[Subwoofer]

The Busby data is consistent with Jim Wilson's P312 map from Cromo2, of course not all of these will be DF27....

[Subwoofer]

Yes but is this 20% of P312 or 20% overall ?

It won't make much difference anyway (because of the levels of P312 in Ireland) but it would be nice to know before I attempt a response....

[Subwoofer]

Any chance of answering the question then ?...

[Subwoofer]

Indeed...

[Subwoofer]

Okey dokey, after the last experience could you this time explain exactly what you mean by 20% please rather than leaving people trying to guess ?...

[Subwoofer]

Don't see it or don't want to consider it ?...

[Subwoofer]

Yes indeed, the 'unthinkable' answer is modern Western DNA contains a lot of ancient DNA from the Yamna : )...

[Subwoofer]

Perhaps you could make yourself clearer in the future, is this how you came up with 20% for DF27 in Ireland as well ?...

[Subwoofer]

Been over it before, Davidski used S. American Indians as a proxy for ANE but it didn't work very well. After that he produced another calculator that used the Stone Age Siberians that are presumed to be from (or close to) the population that ANE formed in. This calculator didn't show any ANE in Lochsbour...

[Subwoofer]

There was no sign of ANE in WHG, you've brought this up before, SHG isn't an ancestral component of modern European populations so is irrelevant to this discussion.

Yes we know CWC was predominately R1a and related to the Yamna culture (who were predominantly R1b) via autosomal DNA, so...