Problem with E-CTS1975 in new Y tree

[wbull]

Hi Elise,
Yes. I am a member of the E-M35 project's discussion forum.
I wrote about this problem in my topic:
http://community.haplozone.net/index...3.msg35014#new
Victor

[wbull]

On my kit #220004 page I have - Your Confirmed Haplogroup is E-CTS1975.
In Genograthic my paternal branch is E -CTS10912.
My brother kit#262940 have Your Predicted Haplogroup is E-L542.
Why is there difference in terminal SNP?
In new Haplotree I placed in branch with PAGES00102+...

[wbull]

E-L618* is ancestral sub. for widespread in Europe E-V13+ sub.
All V13+ have L618 positive, but L618* have L618 positive and V13 negative.
more see in topic: http://community.haplozone.net/index.php?topic=2983.0...

[wbull]

I belong to a very rare E-L618* subclade. There are only 5 members in this subclade except me and not one of them is not matched with me by YSTR....

[wbull]

Dear Jim,

I understand.
But I'm a little inaccurate. 2.72% it is the likelihood that my brother and I have the MRCA at a distance of one generation.
That's what I meant when I said that it changes our views.
At FTDNA it turns out that the coincidence of all 37 markers...

[wbull]

My brother and I have 2 or 3 mismatcs on 37 markers.
see: http://forums.familytreedna.com/show...271#post358271

[wbull]

Unfortunately I don't know any cases where this has happened.
But the FTDNA site shows the probability of this event is 2.72%....

[wbull]

The age of the father was 27 and 33 years....

[wbull]

I agree with you, but I think that all such cases should be thoroughly investigated, because it changes our views on the interpretation of the Y STR results....

[wbull]

I think that trying to find private SNPs (private subclade) it is not good idea.
There is not any doubt that we are brothers, because we have rare haplotype.
For example, on 25 or 37 markers I have only one match. It is my brother....

[wbull]

I received my brother Y37 results.
However, results are strange: we have difference in the two markers. I have DYS385b=20, DYS460 =11, the brother DYS385b=19, DYS460 =10. Besides my brother has a micro allele in DYS 464 and I have not.
There is a bug testing or our science does not w...

[wbull]

The third time the transfer of the expected date my mtHVR1toMega result very annoying and strikes a blow to the reputation of FTDNA.

[wbull]

New date of 08/10/2012 for my FF too.

[wbull]

You are lucky beggars still.
Today I have message about my FF:
"Your expected date has recently been updated to reflect the current timeframe for your results to be ready. We sincerely appreciate your continued patience and cooperation. One of the following circumstances applies...

[wbull]

What is mean none?...