Regarding the other hypothesis to explain the German examples of FGC23343+, Wikipedia has a great page that links to some interesting accounts of specific auxiliary units in the Roman army.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...iary_regiments
To me, the hypothesis surrounding the Oleron recruits in de Turenne's forces during the Thirty Years' War still seems a little tidier because the skeletal unit histories presented in that link don't show one obvious chain of events linking Rheinbach/Ahrweiler (Schoenenberg) to Wallenfangen/Saarwellingen (Leinenbach) through the Romans.
The relevant Roman units would have originally been raised in Aquitania--but with later multi-national transfers/recruits. There's not really much sense of ethnic cohesion in these units maybe beyond the first few years of their existence, despite their names. Most of the available evidence links them to camps in Germania Superior, mainly on the east side of the Rhine, around Frankfurt, with some satellite camps further south in the Frankish region of the modern state of Bavaria. Obviously there could have been excursions or subsequent migrations significantly further to the west to Saarlouis or up north to the Bonn area, which I believe would then have been considered part of Germania Inferior.
Every time I have to add a new element, the scenario just appears less convincing, even though the evidence I'm working from is so thin that almost no variant can be regarded as outrageous.
I think I gave a reference earlier to the use of Basque auxiliaries to put down a rebellion in Batavia/northern Germany in 69 A.D., but the applicability to FGC23343+ is more questionable. They seem to have been recruited by Galba when he was governor of Tarragona, which is pretty wide of Poitou/Oleron, in eastern Spain, just outside of what is considered Basque country today, I believe.
https://books.google.com/books?id=hH...s%2069&f=false
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...iary_regiments
To me, the hypothesis surrounding the Oleron recruits in de Turenne's forces during the Thirty Years' War still seems a little tidier because the skeletal unit histories presented in that link don't show one obvious chain of events linking Rheinbach/Ahrweiler (Schoenenberg) to Wallenfangen/Saarwellingen (Leinenbach) through the Romans.
The relevant Roman units would have originally been raised in Aquitania--but with later multi-national transfers/recruits. There's not really much sense of ethnic cohesion in these units maybe beyond the first few years of their existence, despite their names. Most of the available evidence links them to camps in Germania Superior, mainly on the east side of the Rhine, around Frankfurt, with some satellite camps further south in the Frankish region of the modern state of Bavaria. Obviously there could have been excursions or subsequent migrations significantly further to the west to Saarlouis or up north to the Bonn area, which I believe would then have been considered part of Germania Inferior.
Every time I have to add a new element, the scenario just appears less convincing, even though the evidence I'm working from is so thin that almost no variant can be regarded as outrageous.
I think I gave a reference earlier to the use of Basque auxiliaries to put down a rebellion in Batavia/northern Germany in 69 A.D., but the applicability to FGC23343+ is more questionable. They seem to have been recruited by Galba when he was governor of Tarragona, which is pretty wide of Poitou/Oleron, in eastern Spain, just outside of what is considered Basque country today, I believe.
https://books.google.com/books?id=hH...s%2069&f=false
Comment