Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

67 str Marker Match between L21 and U152 L20 and SNP Analysis

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 67 str Marker Match between L21 and U152 L20 and SNP Analysis

    I am kit 559354 and I have a 67 str match with Kit 284099 in the Hill Project, but 284099 is L-21, and I am U152, L20. I corresponded with the administrator for kit 284099 and he said that such a match is unique and rare and that a SNP analysis had to be done to determine common ancestor relationship; so I went ahead and did a SNP analysis and the results are attached.

    I was wondering if people could look at the analysis and come to a conclusion; I lack the expertise.

    Also in the below is correspondence that had been sent to a Project Administrator about a SNP analysis with a Living Cimbri Tribe Member and I was wondering if and how that tied into the Hill analysis time wise – evolution of haplogroups (the SNP's are also attached). The common ancestor with the Cimbri Tribe Member was estimated 3300-1700 ybp (we disproved an Older Scientific Journal that had written that there were no similarities between Dane Cimbri and Living Cimbri in the Alps).

    "I have +225 SNP’s (see attached SNP’s Richard Todd Hunter Kit 559354 (“RTH”)).
    Of these +225 SNP’s, +209 are the same as Cimbri Man (Cimbri has a total +232) (see attached RTH, yellow highlighted are the SNP’s I match with Cimbri Man).
    Cimbri Man does not have 21 SNP’s that I am positive for and these are my positive SNP’s that Cimbri Man does not have:
    L11
    L2
    L20
    L482
    L502
    L51
    L52
    P295
    P310
    P311
    P312
    PF2643
    PF3561
    PF6263
    S23981
    U152
    YSC0000082+
    YSC0000191+
    Z367+
    Z383+
    Z384+
    (see attached RTH, highlighted turquoise are my positive SNP’s that Cimbro Man does not have).


    I do not have 23 SNP’s that Cimbri Man is positive for and those positive Cimbri Man SNP’s are:
    BY 593
    CTS 1450
    CTS 7822
    CTS 9219
    M 12149
    PH 2147
    PH2302
    PH2789
    PH 3362
    PH4505
    PH 4996
    PH 5142
    PH 963
    S12460
    Y11810
    Y5587
    Y5590
    Y5591
    Y5592
    Y5593
    Y5594
    Z2106
    Z2108
    (see attached Cimbri Tribe, green highlighted are those positive SNP’s of Cimbri Man that I do not match).


    -23 (Cimbri Man that I do not have)
    -21 (of Mine that Cimbri Man does not have)
    2 (is the difference)


    I noticed that Cimbri Man had P316 (PF2696) but I read that if a person is R1b (which I presume Cimbri Man is), then it is irrelevant)."
    Attached Files
Working...
X