WIth interests I read the messages about R 1 a and R 1 b.
But there are contradictory opinions about the origin of
R 1 b. Mostly you can write that the R 1 b haplogroup has a
common ancestor with the Basks during the Ice Age in southwest-
France.
But Ellen Levy-Coffman wrote that the Basks are not direct
descendants of the Cro-Magnon men. According to her
R 1b haplgroup has arrived in West-Europe after after Ice-Age.
But there are contradictory opinions about the origin of
R 1 b. Mostly you can write that the R 1 b haplogroup has a
common ancestor with the Basks during the Ice Age in southwest-
France.
But Ellen Levy-Coffman wrote that the Basks are not direct
descendants of the Cro-Magnon men. According to her
R 1b haplgroup has arrived in West-Europe after after Ice-Age.
Comment