Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

My branch

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • My branch

    I was assigned J-Z447 for y-DNA by Geno 2.0, but in paternal story they stopped at J-L210: is it the same ? they answered me the latter could be just a shy of the first, and on the big circle displaying stories from participants, there's one person affirmed J-L210 just close to me at the Center of the circle, a little behind one J-Z467 and more behind, about the middle one person J-M92 a SNP for which I was tested negative, is it possible to be close to me? When I transferred to FTDNA I was confirmed J-CTS2152 and of course tested positive for it, but parallel to it, I mean on my branch of the haplotree there are 5-6 positive tested SNPs like CTS9880, Z455 and Z447( my terminal SNP at Geno 2.0); and about 18 SNPs tested negative like L210, L218 and L227: is it possible? Are all these parallel SNPs both negative and positive synonymous, I mean very closely related, like sibling SNPs if I may say ? How can they at Geno 2.0 tell me that L210- is shy of Z447+ and so consequently of CTS2152+ ?? Please I want to know if Z447+and CTS2152+ are the same SNPs and what is their relationship to L210- and all the other parallel SNPs on my branch both negative and positive ones ??

  • #2
    Originally posted by PhoenicianLebnon View Post
    I was assigned J-Z447 for y-DNA by Geno 2.0, but in paternal story they stopped at J-L210: is it the same ? they answered me the latter could be just a shy of the first, and on the big circle displaying stories from participants, there's one person affirmed J-L210 just close to me at the Center of the circle, a little behind one J-Z467 and more behind, about the middle one person J-M92 a SNP for which I was tested negative, is it possible to be close to me? When I transferred to FTDNA I was confirmed J-CTS2152 and of course tested positive for it, but parallel to it, I mean on my branch of the haplotree there are 5-6 positive tested SNPs like CTS9880, Z455 and Z447( my terminal SNP at Geno 2.0); and about 18 SNPs tested negative like L210, L218 and L227: is it possible? Are all these parallel SNPs both negative and positive synonymous, I mean very closely related, like sibling SNPs if I may say ? How can they at Geno 2.0 tell me that L210- is shy of Z447+ and so consequently of CTS2152+ ?? Please I want to know if Z447+and CTS2152+ are the same SNPs and what is their relationship to L210- and all the other parallel SNPs on my branch both negative and positive ones ??
    Go to http://yfull.com/tree/J2/, scroll down to (search for) J2a1b. Below it you would see J-L210. When moving mouse over 66 SNPs to the right of J-L210, you would see that CTS2152+, L210+ and Z447+ define the same branch.

    W. (Mr.)

    Comment


    • #3
      1- I opened the link through my iPad and went to the SNPs, but all I see is * besides each SNP and no + or - ; what does it mean? 2- again my Haplogroup is J-CTS2152 tested positive for its SNP, and my parallel synonymous SNPs are: CTS2152+, L210-, L218-, L227-,L742- then click on "more": CTS2330-, CTS9000+, Z469-, Z470-, Z471-, Z472-, Z475-, Z476-, Z492-, Z447+, Z450-, Z451-, Z452-,Z453-, Z455+, Z456-, Z457-, Z458+, Z461-, Z463-, Z466-, CTS9425+, CTS9880+ : what does it mean to have the majority of my synonymous SNPs as negative? What would be then the relation of my + SNPs to my - SNPs ? Could it be genealogical or just historical? If my L210 is negative as it's obvious, can I still consider my self part of it? If L210+ is must prevalent among Ashkenazi Jews, what about L210-, and all the other SNPs, whether + or - ?? Specially where CTS2152+ and Z447+ are the most prevalent and where they originated and when? Is L210-, L210+, CTS2152+, CTS2152-, Z447+, Z447- common among Lebanese and specially among Lebanese Christians ( Maronites mainly), and what are their percentages ??

      Comment


      • #4
        I do not know the answer to your specific questions - W. (Mr.)

        Comment


        • #5
          And that fact that on my branch CTS2152 and Z447 are + and L210, L218 and L227 are - ??

          Comment

          Working...
          X