Originally posted by 1798
View Post
So, if you plan to use that paper to bolster your R1b-M269-in-the-FC-Ice-Age-Refuge theory, you're out of luck.
Are you aware that two of the most renowned Indo-European experts, Ivanov and Gamkrelidze, believe the Proto-Indo-Europeans came out of Armenia?
I'm not saying they are right, nor that R1b-M269 came out of Armenia (or elsewhere in eastern Anatolia), but that is one major Urheimat hypothesis.
From what I saw of that paper, they are basing their R1b-M269 theory on modern M269 haplotype variance. I'm not sure that is such a good idea. The SNP trail, IMHO, is a better indicator, and it leads to the shores of the Caspian, as I recall.
Comment