Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Non-Jewish E3b's with....

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #61
    Hi Vinnie,

    For J1, it makes sense to test 67 markers to subdivide the haplogroup into clusters, since most people test negative for the few known subclades. I hope someone eventually discovers some useful J1 SNPs to change this situation

    For E3b, there are many relevant subclades available for testing. While it would be great for E3b research to have everyone test 67 markers and the deep clades, of course this isn't feasible for all individuals. So those who need to watch their finances need to find a happy medium between testing markers and subclades.

    37 markers is a great level for both genealogy and deep ancestry. A close or exact match at 37 markers should be related within genealogical timeframe. And those who are most familiar with E3b haplotypes can often predict the subclade from 37 markers. So individuals who are interested in their deep ancestry can decide whether they're satisfied with a prediction or want to spend the additional funds on a subclade test.

    Sounds like you went the other way, starting with the deep-clade test and thinking about upgrading to 37 as well. Nothing wrong with that either If the deep-clade test shows that your cousin is E3b1a, then the V-series would be offered to you for further testing.

    If you want to let me know your cousin's kit# or Ysearch ID, I can take a look and let you know if I have any specific recommendations.

    Elise
    Last edited by efgen; 12 September 2007, 02:04 AM.

    Comment


    • #62
      Elise, I've ordered the 37 upgrade. The kit# is N52769. Thanks much!

      Vinnie

      Comment


      • #63
        Hi Vinnie,

        Your cousin is one point off from the E3b modal (DYS439=11 instead of 12), so I suspect that he has quite a few matches. I would also expect his deep-clade test to come back as E3b1a, though E3b1c1 is another possibility. If you look at his Haplogroup page, you should see that his close matches are both E3b1a and E3b1c1. This is because the modal (and near-modal) 12-marker haplotype can be found in both of these subclades.

        If your cousin's subclade comes back as E3b1a, he'll be offered the V-series test on his Haplogroup page. Most people who are as close to the modal as your cousin are E3b1a2 (V13), though there are always some exceptions. We can further evaluate once your cousin's 37 markers are in. Some marker values that are further indicative of V13 are DYS460=9, GATAH4=11 and YCA=19-21.

        V13 also has downstream subclades. The E3b project has only one person in one of these subclades, so far -- he's M224+ (E3b1a2b). His markers look just like a V13, so I would have never predicted this. Hopefully the V-series testing will find more people in these subclades.

        Elise
        Last edited by efgen; 12 September 2007, 12:03 PM.

        Comment


        • #64
          For Elise,

          Elise,

          Once again, thanks for the information and your efforts clarifying my haplotypes.

          Once I get the subclade data in and digest the results and what it means, I'll probably upgrade to 37 marker to greater resolve the issue.

          Best Regards,

          Doug
          e3b1man

          Comment


          • #65
            Originally posted by efgen
            Hi Vinnie,

            Your cousin is one point off from the E3b modal (DYS439=11 instead of 12), so I suspect that he has quite a few matches. I would also expect his deep-clade test to come back as E3b1a, though E3b1c1 is another possibility. If you look at his Haplogroup page, you should see that his close matches are both E3b1a and E3b1c1. This is because the modal (and near-modal) 12-marker haplotype can be found in both of these subclades.

            If your cousin's subclade comes back as E3b1a, he'll be offered the V-series test on his Haplogroup page. Most people who are as close to the modal as your cousin are E3b1a2 (V13), though there are always some exceptions. We can further evaluate once your cousin's 37 markers are in. Some marker values that are further indicative of V13 are DYS460=9, GATAH4=11 and YCA=19-21.

            V13 also has downstream subclades. The E3b project has only one person in one of these subclades, so far -- he's M224+ (E3b1a2b). His markers look just like a V13, so I would have never predicted this. Hopefully the V-series testing will find more people in these subclades.

            Elise
            Hi Elise, your prediction was right, and my deep snp shows E3b1a. So I've ordered the v-series and still waiting on the 37 upgrade. At this point, can I hypothesize that my Sicilian grandfather may have been descended from Albanians who migrated to Sicily? His town is not too far east of the area still known as "The Plain of the Albanians" on the north coast of the island. I taught ESL to a number of Kosovar Albanians a few years back and I have other Albanian friends; do I have to wait for more testing before telling them we might be "cousins"? Unfortunately, these results don't shed any light on how my grandfather's surname is documented as an old French-Jewish name...

            Vinnie
            Last edited by vinnie; 29 September 2007, 11:56 AM.

            Comment


            • #66
              Originally posted by Rossi
              One major point. The Lost Tribes were not Jews. There were pagans.

              actually they were hebrew

              Comment


              • #67
                Originally posted by Jim Denning
                actually they were hebrew

                the laws of ireland were written at tara. which btw is in danger of being destructed search TARA WATCH
                these laws were done by ollam folla which means seer. ollam folla is probably Jerimiah. Ireland was the only other place for cities of santuaries. and alot more .Olgham the keltoi vocabuary used no vowel points like hebrew.The druids were christian after joseph of aremathea and lasuruz converted them. and caradoc aka caractus after being btrayed was allowed to stay alive in rome liing of the taxes of britian . his wife pricilla started the church in rome in there house along with paul and pauls half brother a roman senator.
                they converted rome . if you want to learn more read "Did st paul visit Britian" by G.W.Morgan

                It was the church as usual not understanding any other belief then theirs killed them unless they became roman. whose the pagan ?

                BTW SAVE TARA

                http://www.tarawatch.org/

                Comment


                • #68
                  Non-Jewish E3b

                  I just received my 25 test results today and I have to wait a few more days for my full 37 test results.

                  I am a bit confused by my results. I am N2689 in Family Tree and QG5W4 in ySearch.

                  I have definite Italian ancestry. My great-grandfather was born in Poggiomarino, Italy (on the slopes of Mt. Vesuvius) and we have no known Jewish ancestry. I have a few other Italians as matches, but I also have a number of matches with people of English and German ancestry as well as some of Jewish ancestry.

                  Any thoughts on this?

                  Do my results put me in the E3b1 alpha cluster?

                  Thanks

                  Comment


                  • #69
                    Originally posted by AlexVA
                    I just received my 25 test results today and I have to wait a few more days for my full 37 test results.

                    I am a bit confused by my results. I am N2689 in Family Tree and QG5W4 in ySearch.
                    I see that you have now posted your full 37 markers. Here is your Ysearch neighbor list:

                    http://www.ysearch.org/search_result...ting_marker=23

                    You are pretty far away from everyone else. Your neighbors, such as they are, seem to be more E3b1c (formerly known as E3b3).

                    Have you joined the E3b Project, and then asked for a classification in their forum?

                    Comment


                    • #70
                      Non-Jewish E3b

                      Ii have uploaded my results to the E3b project but haven't had a chance to ask for their take on my results. I thought my results would give me greater clarity, but I am more confused now. I have many fewer matches now and no one seems to be a particularly close match. I also don't seem to fit in any of the E3b1 clusters.

                      Comment


                      • #71
                        We have responded to AlexVA's question on the E3b project's Double-Helix forum:

                        http://community.haplozone.net/index.php?topic=340.0

                        Larry, thanks for the redirect.

                        Elise

                        Comment


                        • #72
                          Originally posted by MMaddi
                          The other factor is that FTDNA's database is skewed in a couple of ways. First of all, those with British Isles ancestry are overrepresented, since most American genealogists are of British Isles ancestry. That doesn't relate to your situation, but the other overrepresented group in the FTDNA database is those of Jewish ancestry. One of the big breakthroughs in genetic genealogy was the discovery of the Cohen Modal Haplotype (CMH) several years ago. This showed that Jewish men who had a history of being in the priestly class (many surnamed Cohen) did have similar results, called CMH. This is in J1 and some in J2, not E3b, but I believe it caused many Jewish genealogists, beyond their percentage in the general population, to test their DNA to see if they have the CMH. So, Jewish ancestry is somewhat over-represented in the database here.

                          Mike Maddi

                          Well said, Mike. This is what the RAO section of my personal page shows (I don’t have exact matches.


                          Belarus (330) Ashkenazi 1

                          England (13738) - 2

                          Hungary (575) Ashkenazi 1

                          Israel (91) Ashkenazi 1

                          Poland (1633) Ashkenazi 1

                          Scotland (6069) - 2

                          Ukraine (765) Ashkenazi 1

                          United Kingdom (4439) - 1

                          I must discard one of the English matches, because he belongs to haplogroup V13. Thus, I get five Ashkenazi and four British 10/12 matches.
                          Things like this makes people go a bit crazy (me included)

                          Roberto (Spanish paternal lineage)

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X