Value or Weight of Longest Segment vs Segment Shared in Determining Relationships

[USMC7312]

When you are looking at these two values in cM: Longest Segment and Shared Segments, which is more important?

For example:
1. Mother has a cM of 98 for the Longest Segment and 508 for Shared Segments
2. Son has a cM of 97 for the Longest Segment and 297 for Shared Segments

In looking at the research by Bettinger, he says:
1. Half 1C average Shared vs Longest cM 458/75.
2. 1C1R average Shared vs Longest cM 440/62
3. Great Aunt Uncle average Shared vs Longest cM 844/86.
4. Great Grandparent average Shared vs Longest cM 856/102

If you were to give precedence to Longest Segment then Great Aunt/Uncle or Great Grandparent would be more appropriate, but if you give more weight to Share Segment value then Half 1C or 1C1R would be better.

I have attached the chart I used

[jimbirk]

Not a direct answer _ I suggest you read Blaine Bettinger's research work on shared cMs

https://thegeneticgenealogist.com/2017/08/26/august-2017-update-to-the-shared-cm-project/

[ltd-jean-pull]

These are just averages, but the ranges of possible shared DNA is wide. A real life example: one of my relatives shares 407cM with a 1C1R, longest segment 56 (according to FtDNA)

In terms of steps of genetic distance a gt-grandparent and a gt-aunt or gt-uncle are the same. DNA alone can not tell you which it is, and it may even be some other relationship.

[capitulinagarage]

I need advice. My eight-year-old son is rapidly gaining weight. Our doctor says it’s genetics, but my husband and I have never been overweight. Could it be genetic?

[Jim Barrett]

I need advice.

Get a second medical opinion!

[John McCoy]

By all means, get second opinion. Sudden weight gain in children is not normal. Suggest a physician specializing in internal medicine, if possible. "Genetics" is not likely to explain a sudden weight gain. Could be a metabolic abnormality or worse, but could equally well be something benign. Some basic tests could rule out some possibilities.