Tweet
I sent my results (both 23&Me and Geno) + my mother's Geno results to Doug and was wondering if someone could help me figure out, most likely, what side my of my parents my 'Jewish' results are coming from? I am still waiting for my mom's 23&Me results.
Doug said that the Geno data is very noisy and that the 23 data is much better for his analysis - but I thought we might be able to disern something regarding this ancestry? I am wondering why, on the Geno reults, I show middle eastern and Jewish but not my mother yet my X (which is obviously from her) shows middle eastern. Doug said not to pay attention to the X.??? So I am trying to see where I should start looking? Seemingly my father's side which would be even less likely Iw ould think from what I know obout the records.
Here are the McDonald reults for both our Geno and my 23 results by Doug:
My Geno:
This analysis uses only 57785 markers and is quite noisy.
Most likely fit is 82.9% (+- 1.1%) Europe (all Western Europe) and 17.1% (+- 1.1%) Mideast (various subcontinents).
The following are possible population sets and their fractions, most likely at the top.
English= 0.816 Georgian= 0.184 or
English= 0.827 Armenian= 0.173 or
English= 0.844 Iranian= 0.156
This looks 16% Jewish plus English, Irish or German
He definately got the English, Irish, and German. But like I said the Jewish is new one for me.
Chromosome Painting - see below attachments:
Mom's Geno:
This analysis uses only 57785 markers and is quite noisy.
Most likely fit is 47.0% (+- 0.0%) Europe (all Western Europe) and 53.0% (+- 0.0%) Europe (all Northeast Europe) which is 100% total Europe.
The following are possible population sets and their fractions, most likely at the top.
French= 0.470 Belorus= 0.530
This looks German, plus a faintly possible 1% American.
Geno2 is so noisy and I have less experience with it, so I am very unsure whether this American is real.
Chromosome Painting - see below attachments:
My 23&Me:
Most likely fit is 53.9% (+- 7.3%) Europe (all Western Europe) and 26.1% (+- 4.4%) Europe (all Northeast Europe) which is 80.0% total Europe and 18.8% (+- 4.0%) Mideast (various subcontinents) and 1.3% (+- 0.8%) S. Asia (various subcontinents)
The following are possible population sets and their fractions, most likely at the top
English= 0.466 Lithuani= 0.284 Jewish= 0.226 Sindhi= 0.023 or
English= 0.470 Lithuani= 0.279 Jewish= 0.224 Pathan= 0.027 or
English= 0.448 Lithuani= 0.297 Jewish= 0.239 N_India= 0.016 or
English= 0.443 Lithuani= 0.302 Jewish= 0.243 S_India= 0.012 or
English= 0.608 Lithuani= 0.221 Armenian= 0.164 N_India= 0.007 or
English= 0.606 Lithuani= 0.222 Armenian= 0.165 S_India= 0.006 or
English= 0.612 Lithuani= 0.218 Armenian= 0.163 Sindhi= 0.007 or
English= 0.612 Lithuani= 0.217 Armenian= 0.163 Pathan= 0.008 or
English= 0.607 Lithuani= 0.223 Armenian= 0.170 Hazara= 0.000 or
French= 0.516 Lithuani= 0.347 Armenian= 0.117 N_India= 0.020
There is no need to do Geno2 ... 23andme is much better.
This is probably in fact ¾ German and the rest Jewish. But there could in fact be other northern or western European in there plus the Jewish.
That 1/4 Jewish of the German result was right on - 23 had me at appoximately 7%.
My Chromosome Painting (with the X): The first two are Geno (TL mine and the UY my moms). The last one is my 23.
Can we tell which parent it is most likely coming from - your best guess and thoughts. Thanks!
Doug said that the Geno data is very noisy and that the 23 data is much better for his analysis - but I thought we might be able to disern something regarding this ancestry? I am wondering why, on the Geno reults, I show middle eastern and Jewish but not my mother yet my X (which is obviously from her) shows middle eastern. Doug said not to pay attention to the X.??? So I am trying to see where I should start looking? Seemingly my father's side which would be even less likely Iw ould think from what I know obout the records.
Here are the McDonald reults for both our Geno and my 23 results by Doug:
My Geno:
This analysis uses only 57785 markers and is quite noisy.
Most likely fit is 82.9% (+- 1.1%) Europe (all Western Europe) and 17.1% (+- 1.1%) Mideast (various subcontinents).
The following are possible population sets and their fractions, most likely at the top.
English= 0.816 Georgian= 0.184 or
English= 0.827 Armenian= 0.173 or
English= 0.844 Iranian= 0.156
This looks 16% Jewish plus English, Irish or German
He definately got the English, Irish, and German. But like I said the Jewish is new one for me.
Chromosome Painting - see below attachments:
Mom's Geno:
This analysis uses only 57785 markers and is quite noisy.
Most likely fit is 47.0% (+- 0.0%) Europe (all Western Europe) and 53.0% (+- 0.0%) Europe (all Northeast Europe) which is 100% total Europe.
The following are possible population sets and their fractions, most likely at the top.
French= 0.470 Belorus= 0.530
This looks German, plus a faintly possible 1% American.
Geno2 is so noisy and I have less experience with it, so I am very unsure whether this American is real.
Chromosome Painting - see below attachments:
My 23&Me:
Most likely fit is 53.9% (+- 7.3%) Europe (all Western Europe) and 26.1% (+- 4.4%) Europe (all Northeast Europe) which is 80.0% total Europe and 18.8% (+- 4.0%) Mideast (various subcontinents) and 1.3% (+- 0.8%) S. Asia (various subcontinents)
The following are possible population sets and their fractions, most likely at the top
English= 0.466 Lithuani= 0.284 Jewish= 0.226 Sindhi= 0.023 or
English= 0.470 Lithuani= 0.279 Jewish= 0.224 Pathan= 0.027 or
English= 0.448 Lithuani= 0.297 Jewish= 0.239 N_India= 0.016 or
English= 0.443 Lithuani= 0.302 Jewish= 0.243 S_India= 0.012 or
English= 0.608 Lithuani= 0.221 Armenian= 0.164 N_India= 0.007 or
English= 0.606 Lithuani= 0.222 Armenian= 0.165 S_India= 0.006 or
English= 0.612 Lithuani= 0.218 Armenian= 0.163 Sindhi= 0.007 or
English= 0.612 Lithuani= 0.217 Armenian= 0.163 Pathan= 0.008 or
English= 0.607 Lithuani= 0.223 Armenian= 0.170 Hazara= 0.000 or
French= 0.516 Lithuani= 0.347 Armenian= 0.117 N_India= 0.020
There is no need to do Geno2 ... 23andme is much better.
This is probably in fact ¾ German and the rest Jewish. But there could in fact be other northern or western European in there plus the Jewish.
That 1/4 Jewish of the German result was right on - 23 had me at appoximately 7%.
My Chromosome Painting (with the X): The first two are Geno (TL mine and the UY my moms). The last one is my 23.
Can we tell which parent it is most likely coming from - your best guess and thoughts. Thanks!
Comment