Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Updated Chromosome Browser

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Originally posted by jimbirk View Post
    It appears that FTDNA copied the look of the MyHeritage chromosome browser.
    it also looks just like the Chromosome Browser at 23andMe (except 23andMe only compares up to 5 Profiles to the given Profile).

    Comment


    • #17
      Originally posted by loobster View Post

      it also looks just like the Chromosome Browser at 23andMe (except 23andMe only compares up to 5 Profiles to the given Profile).
      You took the words right out of my mouth.

      New and improved?

      Excuse me while I pour a glass of the New Coke. The one that has no cannabis added, please...

      Comment


      • #18
        I would like to see chromosome painting added to this chromosome browsing. I also don't think the colors contrast enough and the rectangles are too small I also would like to see an in common with feature that scanned through my 1,000 + matches selecting for matches with the segment that I'm working with. Manually going through all of those matches 7 at it time eats up too much time.

        Comment


        • #19
          I like the less clunky look.

          I DON'T LIKE that FTDNA removed the ability to see the not rounded up/down total centiMorgans shared which was found prior by double-clicking a selected match in Chromosome Browser in the resulting pop-up window which also told you total number of DNA segments. Now you can only see the not rounded down/up total by downloading your DNA matches.

          BUT I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY FTDNA completely took away the ability to see/know the total number of DNA segments shared with a match. I shouldn't have to manually add them up from the Detailed Segment Data. If there is just a few no problem but as the count goes up it is a task that didn't have to be done before. Work smarter, not harder. SUGGESTION: add that "#.# centiMorgans in common across # DNA segments" back somewhere.

          Just seeing the largest segment size on the DNA match page doesn't tell me everything.

          If I'm missing where this data is now located, someone let me know.

          Comment


          • #20
            isn't the number of segments shown on the DNA Update screen?

            3rd column - Shared Segments

            Comment


            • #21
              Originally posted by AFH View Post
              I would like to see chromosome painting added to this chromosome browsing. I also don't think the colors contrast enough and the rectangles are too small I also would like to see an in common with feature that scanned through my 1,000 + matches selecting for matches with the segment that I'm working with. Manually going through all of those matches 7 at it time eats up too much time.
              Window dressing (chromosome painting) might be nice. Information (or merchandise) provided might be considered more important than window dressing.

              This ia always the case with whatever drives retail marketing, both in the product and the window dressing. It's whatever sells the most.

              Comment


              • #22
                Last time I looked, they had changed it so if you had clicked / checked profiles and then chose Chromosome Browser, it automatically compared those matches on the Chromosome Browser - no need to click "Compare" and no list showing until/unless you clicked "Update Selected Matches". I thought that change was fine.

                Now I see they have made yet another change -- this one I dislike intensely - the grey lines have disappeared -- now you cannot count down to see which line it is -- AND it is not easy to see which Chromosome it is because no clear separation there either. Since which color changes when you update - this makes it very hard to trace who is who and how they compare on each chromosome. I do not like the appearance now at all.

                What do others feel about these two changes?

                Comment


                • #23
                  Originally posted by loobster View Post
                  Last time I looked, they had changed it so if you had clicked / checked profiles and then chose Chromosome Browser, it automatically compared those matches on the Chromosome Browser - no need to click "Compare" and no list showing until/unless you clicked "Update Selected Matches". I thought that change was fine.

                  Now I see they have made yet another change -- this one I dislike intensely - the grey lines have disappeared -- now you cannot count down to see which line it is -- AND it is not easy to see which Chromosome it is because no clear separation there either. Since which color changes when you update - this makes it very hard to trace who is who and how they compare on each chromosome. I do not like the appearance now at all.

                  What do others feel about these two changes?
                  I'm very confused by what you are asking - or perhaps it is by the terms you are using that are not specific enough for me to understand the problem.
                  ...so if you had clicked / checked profiles and then chose Chromosome Browser...
                  There are no profiles, Here they are called "matches". If you choose Chromosome Browser it essentially brings up your most prominent matches. I don't see anything regarding "Update Selected Matches", at this point, so you may be correct if that was changed. <?>

                  The feature invites you to compare up to 7 matches, then click "compare". Then we see all the colorful bar graphs, and another tab that invites "Update Selected Matches". That just brings you back to the page where you initially selected those that you did.

                  Now I see they have made yet another change -- this one I dislike intensely - the grey lines have disappeared -- now you cannot count down to see which line it is -- AND it is not easy to see which Chromosome it is because no clear separation there either. Since which color changes when you update - this makes it very hard to trace who is who and how they compare on each chromosome. I do not like the appearance now at all.
                  I'm totally confused by your commentary. Here is what I see: Many numbered grey bars, the first 7 of which I have chosen as the maximum limit of available choices. They contain data expressed by color bars. These bars are numbered as the 23 found in the genome. The ones that remain blank indicate that you have no matches on these particular chromosomes with those matches that you have selected to compare.

                  It's all 'window dressing', meant to be impressive and attractive, perhaps a distraction, maybe even considered to be an attractive nuisance. The data remains the same. It's a novelty. The colors are pretty. How impressive, how nice. <yawn>
                  Last edited by Carpathian; 8th November 2018, 10:56 PM.

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    You are correct - I should have said "Matches" not "Profiles"

                    One can go directly to Chromosome Browser - I was not referring to that.

                    I was referring to where one first goes to "Matches" and chooses / selects some Matches, then clicks "Chromosome Browser" from the Matches page.
                    When one does that, then it is now automatcally comparing those selected, and one sees "Update Selected Matches" in upper right.
                    And in that case, ie coming from Matches to Chromosome Browser, one now does not see the list of matches (starting with "most prominent", as you put it) unless/until one clicks on "Update Selected Matches"

                    Since I currently see the grey lines I was talking about - either it was due to using a different Browser, or they are back.
                    (Am currently using a different computer in a different facility)
                    Last edited by loobster; 9th November 2018, 03:53 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Originally posted by loobster View Post
                      You are correct - I should have said "Matches" not "Profiles"

                      One can go directly to Chromosome Browser - I was not referring to that.

                      I was referring to where one first goes to "Matches" and chooses / selects some Matches, then clicks "Chromosome Browser" from the Matches page.
                      When one does that, then it is now automatcally comparing those selected, and one sees "Update Selected Matches" in upper right.
                      And in that case, ie coming from Matches to Chromosome Browser, one now does not see the list of matches (starting with "most prominent", as you put it) unless/until one clicks on "Update Selected Matches"
                      I followed all the steps you described and I got the same result. Since I have virtually no use for this supposedly 'new and improved' feature nor complaint about it, I can only say that the new format imposed is an insignificant issue (at least for me).

                      "Since I currently see the grey lines I was talking about - either it was due to using a different Browser, or they are back.
                      (Am currently using a different computer in a different facility)"

                      The grey bar lines are those as I described them. I didn't initially understand why they are being displayed in this new feature, perhaps no more than you did - because when they contain no information in most of those chromosomes, seeing these empty grey bars is useless.

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Originally posted by Carpathian View Post

                        The grey bar lines are those as I described them. I didn't initially understand why they are being displayed in this new feature, perhaps no more than you did - because when they contain no information in most of ose chromosomes, seeing these empty grey bars is useless.

                        Please do not put words in my mouth.
                        Without the grey lines in the pictured chromosomes, it was truly horrible, and I hope they never disappear again!!
                        Last edited by loobster; 10th November 2018, 01:24 AM.

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          I agree with loobster that the light gray background for each match on each chromosome is useful, and it would be harder to visualize which match's segments were on a particular chromosome without them. Both MyHeritage and 23andMe also use the same gray bars to illustrate the chromosomes. FTDNA previously used a very dark blue or black background for the base color for each chromosome. It would seem that the three companies see the need to have a background for chromosomes, perhaps determined through design testing.

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Originally posted by loobster View Post

                            Please do not put words in my mouth.
                            Words, indeed. Including this one:
                            "perhaps"

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Muito bom Saber Disso.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X