
Family Finder Advanced Topics Advanced discussion about Family Tree DNA's Family Finder Product. 

Thread Tools  Display Modes 
#21




I say "at least" because I only used the basic probability curve for a single observation. I intuit that the probability curve for 3 successive observations must be considerably steeper as each successive observation is likely to bring their collective average closer to the population mean. But I'm still debating the methodologically proper way to derive those figures.
I'm working with the binomial distribution function in Excel right now, and my first naive attempts return figures like a ~96% probability of an NPE. 
#22




Quote:
I think this may be the correct methodology. 1. Identify the minimum point in the curve where 4 successive observations will still return a final matching probability of 100%. 2. Calculate the noncumulative binomial distribution in Excel for 4 successes in 4 trials and where the individual probability being the entire area in the curve under my minimum point. This represents the chance that my calculated probability of two 4th cousins who connect to MRCAs through their respective direct paternal lines is less than 100%. Subtracting that figure from 100% would yield a figure representing the onesided confidence level that the probability of an NPE in this specific scenario is no less than 100%. Which coincidentally is just about ~96%. 
#23




I guess this is no big deal. It's just X^4 where X=the area of the curve under my minimum point.

#24




I guess attempting to verbalize my logic might be helpful. If anyone can point out an obvious flaw it would be appreciated.
The final stages of my matching probability calculation are based on the expected volume of ancestral DNA held by each donor. Therefore, I'm only concerned with the variability in grandparental contribution on a net basis. That there are alternative scenarios of fluctuation in contribution percentage at individual points in the chain of descent doesn't matter provided they all result in the same volume of ancestral DNA held by the donor. So the simplest way of calculating a topsided, as opposed to iterative adjustment, to my basic calculation is to multiply the preliminary expected volume of ancestral DNA by X^Y, where: X=the typical grandparental contribution % in this chain of descent/the population average contribution % Y=the number of grandparental relationships in the chain of descent In the confidence calculation I use a binomial distribution where the # of successes equals the # of trials, and the number of trials equals the # of grandparental relationships in the line of descent and the iterative probability equals that for the same value (i.e., typical grandparental contribution %) on a singletrial distribution. I think this is justified because the singletrial distribution is simply a specific instance of the overall binomial distribution. The only differences are the number of trials. I think it would be a mistake to use the singletrial distribution and assume one trial to achieve the net grandparental contribution % because we know that the average of sample values moves closer to the population average when we increase the sample size. There is simply too much variation among individual observations to reflect any actual multigeneration descent scenario accurately. I wish there were less technical language to describe this logic. Maybe there is, but I have yet to discover it. In any case, I think this logic is pretty solid. Last edited by Frederator; 14th July 2017 at 11:28 PM. 
Bookmarks 
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)  
Thread Tools  
Display Modes  


Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
Surname probability  fostert  Paternal Lineage (YDNA STR) Advanced  5  29th June 2016 10:07 PM 
Matching Probability % for 3rd Cousins  Songbill  DNA and Genealogy for Beginners  2  10th January 2015 03:18 PM 
Understanding Y haplotype matching probability  PNGarrison  Scientific Papers  2  15th November 2014 12:07 PM 
A question on probability...  constant_d  Paternal Lineage (YDNA STR) Advanced  5  16th July 2006 08:18 AM 
Probability of 37/37 match between brothers  gpenner  DNA and Genealogy for Beginners  3  16th April 2006 01:23 AM 