Go Back   Family Tree DNA Forums > General Interest > DNA Success Stories

DNA Success Stories How DNA helped solve a family brick wall. We encourage you to publish your story here. This board is open to customers and visitors.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 3rd May 2017, 04:14 PM
lab lab is offline
FTDNA Customer
 
Join Date: Aug 2016
Posts: 42
Best Place to Begin?

Since people on this forum have had success with DNA, here it a dilemma I have that I could use some advice on. Where does someone begin when their family tree is wrong?

It started with weird ethnicity results that made absolutely no sense with what I had in my tree. So, I began contacting people within my tree (people within the 3rd cousin-ish range) who were supposedly related to me and asking them to upload to Gedmatch to see if we were indeed related, but haven't been able to find a connection. What now? Obviously something is wrong, and right now I don't have the option of testing more family members. I haven't had the best luck contacting people either, most people haven't responded or they themselves are in a predicament where they know nothing about their family either.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 3rd May 2017, 05:34 PM
MoberlyDrake MoberlyDrake is online now
mtDNA: T2b5 | Y-DNA: J-M172
 
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 1,308
First of all, if the only ethnicity results you have are from FTDNA, ignore them. If you have tested at all 3 companies and they all say the same thing, you might want to pay some attention. But FTDNA's are the worst.

Where did you get your tree? Was it through years of careful research with primary documents as sources? Or did you just copy someone's online tree? How do you know it's wrong? If it's just copied it probably is wrong, unless you had the good fortune to copy the tree of a meticulous researcher.

I haven't had much luck getting replies here. And I don't have any idea what common ancestors I share with my 2nd to 4th cousins here, much less 3rd to 5th. If I hadn't tested at Ancestry too, I'd be thinking maybe my tree was wrong too. But at Ancestry, my mother has plenty of very close matches to verify her Calvin line, plus plenty of very close matches to verify two of her German lines. I haven't gotten any matches to verify any of the ancestry of her French grandfather who immigrated in 1905. Less than a half dozen matches here in these lines and they are quite distant.

As far her brick wall lines go, I'm not getting anywhere. It's hard to find something when you don't know what it is you're looking for.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 3rd May 2017, 11:41 PM
lab lab is offline
FTDNA Customer
 
Join Date: Aug 2016
Posts: 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by MoberlyDrake View Post
First of all, if the only ethnicity results you have are from FTDNA, ignore them. If you have tested at all 3 companies and they all say the same thing, you might want to pay some attention. But FTDNA's are the worst.

Where did you get your tree? Was it through years of careful research with primary documents as sources? Or did you just copy someone's online tree? How do you know it's wrong? If it's just copied it probably is wrong, unless you had the good fortune to copy the tree of a meticulous researcher.

I haven't had much luck getting replies here. And I don't have any idea what common ancestors I share with my 2nd to 4th cousins here, much less 3rd to 5th. If I hadn't tested at Ancestry too, I'd be thinking maybe my tree was wrong too. But at Ancestry, my mother has plenty of very close matches to verify her Calvin line, plus plenty of very close matches to verify two of her German lines. I haven't gotten any matches to verify any of the ancestry of her French grandfather who immigrated in 1905. Less than a half dozen matches here in these lines and they are quite distant.

As far her brick wall lines go, I'm not getting anywhere. It's hard to find something when you don't know what it is you're looking for.

I'm not just going by ethnicity, not by a long shot. I know that is faulty methodology. For what it's worth however, I have uploaded to multiple sites and they have all pretty much said the same thing. The percentages of some of the ethnicities (very large) plus the fact the tester is being matched with actual people of that ethnicity leave little doubt that it is for real.


The tree I have constructed I have been working on for a couple years & is well researched and documented with original sources (when I first started genealogy I made the mistake of just copying information, but have since learned better!). I know my tree is wrong because I'm not matching with people I'm supposed to be matching with, and the ethnic percentages make absolute zero sense. I had connected with some relatives (more distant) prior to the DNA test and we had already figured out our relationship/ common ancestor. Yet, no dice on a genetic match.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 4th May 2017, 12:34 PM
MoberlyDrake MoberlyDrake is online now
mtDNA: T2b5 | Y-DNA: J-M172
 
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 1,308
Quote:
Originally Posted by lab View Post
I had connected with some relatives (more distant) prior to the DNA test and we had already figured out our relationship/ common ancestor. Yet, no dice on a genetic match.
How distant? I suppose they are close enough that you have a fairly good probability that they should match on a DNA test?

Do you know which branch of your tree the error is likely to be in?

I had to cut out a whole branch of my tree when Y-DNA testing revealed an NPE. It took me a year to sort out where the NPE occurred and prove it by DNA testing. That gave me the name of my mother's great-grandfather. I easily found his parents, but I've been trying for years now to find their parents. When you can't find documents, it appears atDNA testing is not very helpful at the 3rd great-grandparent level.

Is the error in a line where you might be able to use Y-DNA testing if you could locate some willing male cousins?

Do you have matches closer than 3rd to 5th cousins? I'd work with the closest.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 4th May 2017, 03:44 PM
dcx4610 dcx4610 is offline
FTDNA Customer
 
Join Date: Jul 2016
Posts: 24
It really depends on your goals. If you live in America, are you wanting to see where you ancestors came from or just delve into your ethnicity?

Start with your family tree and use autosomal DNA and related testing to help fill in the gaps and get more answers.

I do think ancestry.com probably has the most complete family tree service. Start by finding out the full names of your parent's parents. Once you have that information, start looking at the census records on Ancestry.com. It's very easy in most cases keep finding grandmothers/grandfathers at that point. Once you hit the 1700s it will get a little tricky and that's where DNA evidence helps.

It's also helpful to find out where your great parents settled and will point to clues where they may have come from.
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 4th May 2017, 05:12 PM
lab lab is offline
FTDNA Customer
 
Join Date: Aug 2016
Posts: 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by MoberlyDrake View Post
How distant? I suppose they are close enough that you have a fairly good probability that they should match on a DNA test?

Do you know which branch of your tree the error is likely to be in?

I had to cut out a whole branch of my tree when Y-DNA testing revealed an NPE. It took me a year to sort out where the NPE occurred and prove it by DNA testing. That gave me the name of my mother's great-grandfather. I easily found his parents, but I've been trying for years now to find their parents. When you can't find documents, it appears atDNA testing is not very helpful at the 3rd great-grandparent level.

Is the error in a line where you might be able to use Y-DNA testing if you could locate some willing male cousins?

Do you have matches closer than 3rd to 5th cousins? I'd work with the closest.

How did you go about finding the NPE? That's probably what I'm dealing with here but I don't really know where to begin since I can't really test any other family right now. I have a couple 2-4th cousins but not many and none have responded to me.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 4th May 2017, 06:25 PM
MoberlyDrake MoberlyDrake is online now
mtDNA: T2b5 | Y-DNA: J-M172
 
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 1,308
I had my 1st cousin do a Y-DNA test because I had a brick wall in my Mobley line and thought it might help. I suppose you know that a Y-DNA test follows the father's father's father's etc. line. When his results came back, he matched 5 or 6 Hamptons (more now, 7 years later) and absolutely no Mobleys. Checking censuses revealed that there were Hamptons living not far from the Mobleys in several generations and locations, but I decided to start with a situation where a Hampton was the next household to my mother's supposed great-grandfather, because of what I thought were suspicious circumstances surrounding her grandfather's placement in an orphanage. I had already done a Family Finder test on my mother. I managed to locate a descendant of the brother of the Hampton suspect to do the Family Finder test and when his results came back he and my mother were 3rd cousin matches.

This was back in 2010-2011 when atDNA testing was new and Ancestry hadn't yet gotten into the act. Now my mother has a few more very close matches descended from the Hampton neighbor. Records quickly revealed his parents names. But that just gave me two brick walls, which neither traditional research nor DNA have broken through.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 6th May 2017, 05:17 AM
DaveInGreece DaveInGreece is offline
FTDNA Customer
 
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: Greece
Posts: 124
lab,

You haven't said what ethnicity results you are getting and what you were expecting. Are you certain there's no logical explanation for the difference? What information are you basing your expectations on?

You mentioned that you don't match people from your tree "within the 3rd cousin-ish range". What relationships exactly? As far as I know (and this is being actively discussed in some groups) there are no proven cases of second cousins once removed (or closer) not sharing autosomal DNA, but it's widely accepted that 5-10% of 3rd cousins don't share DNA and around 50% of fourth cousins don't share DNA. So, unless you've tested people who are 2nd-once-removed or closer you can't be sure that the tree is wrong based on the lack of a DNA match.

You said that you do match people who have the ethnicity you weren't expecting to see in your ancestry. How close are these matches?
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 6th May 2017, 03:55 PM
lab lab is offline
FTDNA Customer
 
Join Date: Aug 2016
Posts: 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveInGreece View Post
lab,

You haven't said what ethnicity results you are getting and what you were expecting. Are you certain there's no logical explanation for the difference? What information are you basing your expectations on?

You mentioned that you don't match people from your tree "within the 3rd cousin-ish range". What relationships exactly? As far as I know (and this is being actively discussed in some groups) there are no proven cases of second cousins once removed (or closer) not sharing autosomal DNA, but it's widely accepted that 5-10% of 3rd cousins don't share DNA and around 50% of fourth cousins don't share DNA. So, unless you've tested people who are 2nd-once-removed or closer you can't be sure that the tree is wrong based on the lack of a DNA match.

You said that you do match people who have the ethnicity you weren't expecting to see in your ancestry. How close are these matches?
What are the odds of not matching multiple 3rd cousins though? I have multiple people I connected with on my tree (before testing) that aren't matching, which seems odd to me but based off what you said could be possible.

I was expecting based off my research around 20% French, and 70-75% english/ Irish, the rest just miscellaneous. This tester came up as more than 50% of an ethnicity that hasn't in any way been accounted for (middle eastern). We are not Italian based off my tree, nor are they matching any Italians, which would be the only semi-plausible explanation. Instead, they are matching individuals from the Middle East. Some of the matches are distant but some are as close as 2nd cousin once removed range. I'm not sure how to make those things add up.

Last edited by lab; 6th May 2017 at 04:07 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 6th May 2017, 04:31 PM
ltd-jean-pull ltd-jean-pull is offline
FTDNA Customer
 
Join Date: Jun 2016
Posts: 327
I haven't had any unusual ethnicity results (everyone comes out mostly European with mostly British Isles or Western and Central Europe) that don't contradict the belief that the testers are pretty much from the British Isles.

However, trying to work out matches has been very difficult for one kit in particular. This was supposed to be the "fun & easy" kit, because (unlike some other kits I manage) all the grandparents are known and some lines go back much further.

Between FtDNA and Gedmatch there are only 5 recognisable matches. A 3C (via maternal grandmother), two 3C1R (one the son of the 3C and the other via the maternal grandfather), a 4C2R via the paternal grandmother and a very weak match on Gedmatch (not a match here) with a 1/2 3C via the paternal grandfather. That match is very weak so I am suspicious.

I have no idea whatsoever who everyone else is!

The odds of not matching multiple third cousins are slim. I have seen it on Gedmatch where two 3rd cousins match, but the 1st cousin of one of them doesn't. He does match other 3rd cousins though.

Last edited by ltd-jean-pull; 6th May 2017 at 04:35 PM.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
How do I best begin creating new family members to my account that I can administer? jweaving DNA and Genealogy for Beginners 7 26th November 2016 04:00 PM
Family Finder: How do I begin with making this tree?? jweaving DNA and Genealogy for Beginners 10 18th November 2016 08:22 PM
Search for name or place box andbro DNA and Genealogy for Beginners 5 1st September 2015 05:50 PM
Order Level to begin Y-37 or Y-67 DSproed Paternal Lineage (Y-DNA STR) Advanced 2 14th November 2012 08:20 PM
we begin anew Cats Family Finder Advanced Topics 7 27th July 2010 05:37 PM


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:42 PM.


Family Tree DNA - World Headquarters

1445 North Loop West, Suite 820
Houston, Texas 77008, USA

Phone: (713) 868-1438 | Fax: (832) 201-7147
Copyright 2001-2010 Genealogy by Genetics, Ltd.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.